Pokemon - Silph Co. (PRC97)
Jun 30, 2007 Hylian_Lemon
Trancemander - Great sound quality, though I think your ideas could have been expanded a little more if you had more time.
Tribal Silphs - Loved the interpretation, but the song was just too bland and didn't sound as polished.
Heroin Addict's Haunted Attic - I don't know what to say, man, besides "Can you say suckfest?" Ugh, you don't even deserve a vote from me, so you're not even going in my last place box. Get a life, for crying out loud.
Ok, now I feel better.
Jul 01, 2007 FiremanJoe
Trancemander - A little work and this could become quite a good track
Tribal Silphs - I liked the intro, but later on, the percussion kinda annoyed me a little
Jul 01, 2007 bundeslang
Nutritious - I like the intro, typical for a trance song. The middle part is good as well. The weakness of this song is the non-variation of it, it's the same tune played in different styles. I don't like the ending.
Hylian Lemon - Nice intro. There's enough variation. Some switches (between parts) are a bit weird, but the song is good. The ending is a bit boring.
Deductive Dave - The song starts way to slow, you better cut the first ten seconds and start then. The song is boring and has too many weird parts. The ending is not very interesting.
Jul 01, 2007 Chickenwarlord
Nutritious' is unfortunately short, which is about the exact opposite of what one wants when they're going for a trance style. There's quite a bit of dissonance with all the echoing. Not a bad start at all.
Deductive Dave's piece is crippled by some sort of filtering accident which mutes everything. I like the little allusions to the battle theme, but overall it never really goes anywhere, then ends.
Jul 02, 2007 Nutritious
Dave's mix was a very interesting take on the original. The chanting (I think) at the start sounded real lo fi, maybe it was just the processing on the original. I think it could've used more filling out and adaptation from the original.
Jul 02, 2007 kylenin
Nutritious doesn't do trance very well, but still gets second, because Deductive Dave's entry seemed too simplistic and short. But I suppose if you're doing it last minute ...
Jul 02, 2007 Deductive_Dave
2nd: Trancemander gets second because it's my only other choice. But it's still pretty good. I love it when it gets into the main silph theme at 0:48
Jul 03, 2007 Nario
Jul 03, 2007 Rexy
In the second place squabble, I went with Deductive Dave's track mainly because it felt the more creative of the set. Nutritious's track felt more like a preview if anything; I felt he had the better production of the two however, but when that track was nothing more than a trance buildup, that's what can be a little bit worrying.
I hope this vote gets through okay. Well done for doing okay with PRC97, everyone.