Super Mario RPG Smithy (PRC154)

Votes (7)

Oct 04, 2009 bundeslang
  1. Weapons Demonstration
    Hylian_Lemon
  2. Forging Electrons
    Showroom_Dummy

Hylian Lemon - I like the sampling. The song variates very nice. I like the part around 1:11. The strings are nice. The middle part is a little boring. The end is nice.
Showroom Dummy - Interesting try-outs. I like the drums and the bass as well with the samples, but they are all the same during the whole song. Still a nice experiment.

Very nice songs, it was hard to pick.
Oct 04, 2009 NintenJoe64
  1. Weapons Demonstration
    Hylian_Lemon
  2. Forging Electrons
    Showroom_Dummy

I really enjoyed both remixes, but i felt Hylian_Lemon's had more cohesion to it. I think that this could have be an awesome substitution as the actual Smithy battle part 1 theme. I also liked how actually incorporated parts of the factory theme that plays prior to the Smithy battle. Those drums samples are sick and i wish i had those samples for my remixes!!

I enjoyed, however, how Showroom_Dummy turned that epic orchestra style source in to such an awesome techno remix though. I really enjoyed your instrument selection. Especially that lead synth that plays the higher notes. Awesome remix man!

Of course, i know i can't vote on mine. :D
Oct 04, 2009 Nario
  1. Weapons Demonstration
    Hylian_Lemon
  2. Forging Electrons
    Showroom_Dummy

While I love both songs and would give first place to both of them, at the end of the day, I prefer listening to Hylian Lemon's more. HL gives his arrangement a charm that is lacking in Forging Electrons, such as: cute percussion, funny transitions, and an extra boss remix to boot.
Oct 05, 2009 metalsnakejuice
  1. Weapons Demonstration
    Hylian_Lemon
  2. Forging Electrons
    Showroom_Dummy

It is such a quirky mix. The sounds and textures sound so industrial.

Good work Hylian_Lemon.
Oct 06, 2009 Hylian_Lemon
  1. Forging Electrons
    Showroom_Dummy


This way, we both get 3 more points and therefore look cooler. And I get to make comments.

Showroom_Dummy - Loved the sounds you used in this remix. The part that started at 0:47 was really cool. The last section was interesting, but didn't seem quite right for an ending. The title fit the sound really well. As soon as it started I was like "aahh electrons."

NintenJoe64 - Guitars were awesome. Sometimes the percussion sounded rather fake, like the section starting at 1:36. Interesting arrangement with the choir made me think of The Wind Waker (Jabu Jabu's theme or Tower of the Gods, I think).
Oct 06, 2009 Krow
  1. Weapons Demonstration
    Hylian_Lemon
  2. Forging Electrons
    Showroom_Dummy

Both were great. I had to flip a coin. Yes, I call that strategy.
Oct 06, 2009 Chickenwarlord
  1. Weapons Demonstration
    Hylian_Lemon
  2. Forging Electrons
    Showroom_Dummy

Hylian's felt better developed as a whole. It had the leg up in arrangement and the mad beatz department.
Showroom, yours felt a bit heavy on the verb in places. Both entries were solid.

Nintenjoe: Your guitar tone is hella crowded and abrasive. Maybe making it a little bit cleaner when it's the only thing going on would make for a nice transition. You went a little nuts on the rhythmic tremolo.