Darkwing Duck - Fortress (PRC132)
Nov 03, 2008 bundeslang
Just64helpin - Nice intro. The middle part sounds like a new start, but I like it. The last section isn't adding something to the song.
Txai - I like the drums, but there are too many different samples. Some of them where really nice.
I'm happy I could add your song as well.
Nov 03, 2008 evktalo
My Name is Darkwing Duck had a varying arrangement, but the guitar and especially the drum sounds grated me. That open hihat is damned loud. But overall, nice jazzy romping. The bleepy outro was fun.
Winging It has a very rough sounding intro, it's fun to hear something so rough from HL. :) Very similar to the original with updated sounds. The bass used long notes, which didn't work for such a rhythmical track. Strings had a bit of a similar problem, although there I hear some volume variation, except in the end.
Nov 03, 2008 DZComposer
2 - Not quite the big-band sound. It had a jazzy feel, but there was almost no chord structure in places. It got better when the brass came in near the end. Way too much drums, as well. Especially the hi-hat. More bass please.
3 - This was boring. I never got into it. It was a chore to finish listening to.
Nov 03, 2008 Chickenwarlord
I have to say that I really enjoyed 64's more thought out approach to the source.
Nov 03, 2008 OneUp
I enjoyed Hylian and Txais songs a lot, because this is the way I've always wanted too hear the source being done (but of course, with a real big band). It was really hard, but I chose Txai as 2nd because he used better instruments/synths and better mastering. I like how Hylian played with that lead sound though.
Nov 03, 2008 Hylian_Lemon
Txai - There are some interesting original ideas at the end, but the rest of the mix just stays too close to the source in my opinion.
Nov 04, 2008 Binweasel
(But seriously, for a bloke who really doesn't like drums all that much, I thought those were awesome.)
The other two... Sorry. I haven't had time to familiarize myself with the source, so I can't comment much on the composition or anything. Txai's song kinda rubbed me wrong with the too-loud-cymbals, hence the third-place, otherwise sounded quite good.
I was more of a Bonkers kid, really...
Nov 04, 2008 kylenin
I liked the other two about the same as each other, except that Hylian_Lemon's was too short, so that one got last place.