One Hour Compo - Round 491 (OHC491)

Votes (12)

Mar 08, 2018 daisu64
  1. bloom
    Miyolophone
  2. Exponentially Replicating Oneself
    Misael.K
  3. From the Earth
    Random-storykeeper
Miyo because that mastering and orchestration and CHIPTUNE + orchestration is disgustingly good

Misael K because i love the piece. it is a good.

RSK because the piece seriously struck me as distinctive and unique
Mar 08, 2018 johnfn
  1. air
    garlagan
  2. From the Earth
    Random-storykeeper
  3. bloom
    Miyolophone
YEYYYYYYYYY
Mar 08, 2018 garlagan
  1. bloom
    Miyolophone
  2. Route 6401
    daisu64
  3. seedlings
    johnfn
Mar 08, 2018 Patashu
  1. air
    garlagan
  2. bloom
    Miyolophone
  3. Exponentially Replicating Oneself
    Misael.K
the order I voted for songs in tells a story, hey
Mar 08, 2018 Arcana
  1. bloom
    Miyolophone
  2. Route 6401
    daisu64
  3. OHC 491 Hymn for a Single Seed
    Patashu
This was a very good set of songs.
Mar 08, 2018 Koekepan
  1. See you soon!
    LunacyEcho
  2. From the Earth
    Random-storykeeper
  3. Something meaningful
    GreyHooves
So many great entries - but little details pulled others out of the running, like weak endings.

But such competition.
Mar 09, 2018 Miyolophone
  1. Route 6401
    daisu64
  2. air
    garlagan
  3. See you soon!
    LunacyEcho
daisu: >:(

garlagan: chords are incredible and you really captured the mood of that picture. also the scream-glitch made me laugh/scared

luny: how do you have time to harmonize in an ohc wtf

also shoutout to luau for a really weird and awesome entry!! probably the most intriguing one i heard and deciding not to rank it here was only after quite some deliberation
Mar 11, 2018 LunacyEcho
  1. Route 6401
    daisu64
  2. From the Earth
    Random-storykeeper
  3. bloom
    Miyolophone
Mar 12, 2018 Random-storykeeper
  1. Exponentially Replicating Oneself
    Misael.K
  2. you are a sprout, i'll be your sun
    coolgreenapple
  3. What is it like to be a Seedling?
    Koekepan
Oh BOI here we go.

I don't think I've ever had to make a list of all the entries in a compo and constantly shuffle it around until this compo. Not since...OHC 400? What I'm saying is that picking a top 3 was tough.

1) "Exponentially Replicating Oneself" - Of all the entries, this was the one that worked for me in all aspects. I absolutely love the pitched percussion that comes in at 0:40. Compositionally, I loved the way this piece flowed, and I loved the feeling of pulsation of the first and sometimes fourth beats. The swelling chords/pads make me think of growth and the whole piece has an outdoorsy, sunny vibe, which works great with the theme, in my opinion.

2) "you are a sprout, i'll be your sun" - I love how simple yet effective this is, emotionally. The choices made, vocal-wise, worked pretty well, especially with all the different voice layers being slightly delayed or harmonizing with each other. It all felt very "earthy". The guitar was absolutely on point.

3) "What is it like to be a Seedling?" - I went with Koekepan for my third choice because for the most part, the sound elements work great in this and the composition makes me feel like I'm in the middle of a garden, or just...some area with lots of plants. There were a couple of instruments that made me think of aliens, for some reason? Perhaps that was just me. :P But the overlying idea of this piece was really effective at painting the nature/garden scene.

---------

And here are some other serious contenders:

- "Something meaningful" by GreyHooves
- "bloom" by Miyolophone
- "seedlings" by johnfn
- "Route 6401" by daisu64
- "See you soon!" by LunacyEcho
Mar 13, 2018 GreyHooves
  1. Exponentially Replicating Oneself
    Misael.K
  2. bloom
    Miyolophone
  3. From the Earth
    Random-storykeeper
Misael.K : Really surprised with this one. From the intro, I though it was mostly going to be quirky, but It really evolved into something amazing and deserves first

Miyolophone : You made quite an epic piece here. Very nice mixup with the Orchestral to Chiptune segments

RSK : I really like how reminiscent of Chrono Trigger and Breath of Fire 3 this tune was at the beginning. The Violin and flute were also excellent choices for the theme
Mar 15, 2018 Misael.K
  1. Route 6401
    daisu64
  2. bloom
    Miyolophone
  3. you are a sprout, i'll be your sun
    coolgreenapple
daisu64: this is extremely cute and dancey and green and lovely.

Miyolophone: so much emotion! is this a movie about a sprout?

coolgreenapple: love the gentle guitars with the vocals.


Special mentions to johnfn and Random-storykeeper. I want more voting slots.
 

awesum: coolgreenapple, daisu64, garlagan, johnfn, LunacyEcho, Miyolophone, Random-storykeeper.
good: Arcana, DarkShadow, GreyHooves, luau, Patashu. 
Mar 15, 2018 coolgreenapple
  1. air
    garlagan
  2. Exponentially Replicating Oneself
    Misael.K
  3. What is it like to be a Seedling?
    Koekepan
beat me 123

this was impossible to vote on because of all the greatness