IoG: Lively Town (MnP19)
Jul 23, 2014 hoboka
gercr - Sounds a bit like my remix/cover :P I wonder if you used the same flute sample lol. Anyway, I like how the soundscape sounds much fuller than the original and the percussion is definitely better than mine lol; that detuned crystal synth is pretty neat too. The strings are really fantastic too. The piano ending is pretty clever too, albeit I think the percussion drops off a bit awkwardly but meh.
GrapplingHook - The use of brass is a cool idea. That marimba or xylophone is a nice touch as well. Also the name of your track is pretty clever :D - so yeah this is a pretty cool cover.
Jul 23, 2014 Blaine
Gercr, I really liked the overall feel over your take on this. I think the reverb may have been a little overdone, but overall things worked well and it felt lively.
GrapplingHook, I really liked your snare throughout, it felt very energetic. The rest less so, and I felt the trumpets were sometimes a bit too prominent.
hoboka (I know it's a bonus but I thought I'd give some thoughts anyways), sometimes I felt like some of the accents/emphasis was a little out of place but not all the time. Also, bassoon <3
Jul 23, 2014 GrapplingHook
The twangy... I want to say banjo(?) of gercr's track wasn't something I could get into, and with only two positions to fight over, that pushes Blaine to the top.
Jul 25, 2014 bundeslang
Gercr - Nice way of variating around the source. I did not like the drums in the beginning, but the last part was good.
GrapplingHook - Good choice of instruments, but after a while they became to repetitive.
hoboka - Another nice relax version of this source (which I didn't know before).